Booking and calendars

TidyCal vs Calendly: An Honest Comparison

By LauraPublished 5 October 2022Updated 19 November 20263 min read

TidyCal and Calendly are very similar booking tools, and for many people either will do the job. When I compared them in October 2022, Calendly had extra features I personally needed, such as text reminders, custom email reminders and a custom confirmation page. TidyCal was the cheaper option. Check both before you decide, as features change.

Which is better, TidyCal or Calendly?

I recorded this comparison on 5 October 2022, so treat it as a snapshot of that moment rather than the current picture. Both tools may well have changed since, so do check their websites before you buy.

My honest answer is that it depends on what you need. I still use Calendly myself, but I recommend TidyCal to other people when it suits them better. If you do not need the features I need, TidyCal may be all you want.

What can both of them do?

A lot more than you might expect. When I went through them side by side, both could do the following:

  • Create several different event types, with different lengths and different prices.
  • Offer one-to-one bookings and group bookings, and keep events private.
  • Connect to a location such as Zoom, a physical address or another video tool.
  • Add padding (a gap) before and after a meeting, set the duration, and control how far ahead people can book and how much notice you need.
  • Ask your own questions when people book.
  • Send people to a custom thank you page after booking.
  • Take payments through PayPal and Stripe.

What did Calendly have that TidyCal did not?

These are the differences I found in the video, and the reasons I use Calendly:

  • Text reminders. Calendly could send them, and TidyCal could not at the time.
  • Custom email reminders and follow-ups. In Calendly you can customise them and send them from your own Outlook or Gmail. In TidyCal the reminders were the default ones.
  • A custom confirmation page. Calendly lets you build one with buttons so people can do something else after booking. With TidyCal you either use the default page or redirect to your own thank you page.
  • Reusable schedules. In Calendly I set up an overall schedule once and use it across events. In TidyCal you set availability separately for each event. I do not think either approach is better or worse.
  • A daily limit. In Calendly you can set a maximum number of bookings per day. I could not do that in TidyCal.
  • Extra booking types. Calendly also offers collective events (hosting with another person) and round robin (sharing bookings between team members).
  • One-off meeting times. This is the one I use most. I can pick specific times, even where my diary looks busy, and send them in an email so the person chooses one and it is scheduled for me. It is the main reason I do not use TidyCal.

What did TidyCal have that Calendly did not?

TidyCal has its own private directory that people can use to find businesses and services. I do not know how much it is used, but it is a feature Calendly does not have. On price, TidyCal came out cheaper when I recorded the video, which is a big reason it suits some people, but pricing changes, so check it yourself.

I also mentioned that TidyCal had a roadmap with customised reminders and text reminders on it, but nobody knew how long they would take. If you want to see which tools we recommend for booking and other business admin, take a look at our tech recommendations.

Common questions

Why do you use Calendly rather than TidyCal?

I like text reminders, customised email reminders, a custom thank you page and the one-off meeting times feature. I also like TidyCal's directory, but I need those other features more.

Can both tools take payments?

Yes. Both connected to PayPal and Stripe when I made the video.

Is this comparison up to date?

No, it reflects what I found in October 2022. Check both tools for their current features and pricing before you decide.

Laura, founder of IT Moon

Written by Laura, founder of IT MoonLaura and the Wizards at IT Moon help business owners with websites, email, checkouts and everything techy, in plain English. Last updated 19 November 2026.

Want your booking set-up working properly?

Our Tech Support Hub gives you answers and a weekly Zoom clinic for questions like this one.

See the Tech Support HubBook a free call

Ready for tech that just works?

Tell us what you are working on. A free 15-minute chat will tell you what you need, with no pressure and no jargon.
it moon
fast, friendly, jargon-free tech